Door County Wisconsin's Premier Vacation Guide

Church Hill Inn

2393 Gateway Drive, Sister Bay, WI,
Property ID #

Winter Hours

Open all year!

From the lovely parlors and theme-decorated rooms overlooking pretty grounds to the English-style pub and hot breakfast buffet, Church Hill Inn is absolutely delightful.

Sister Bay Wi lodging, Church Hill Inn, Door County trusted review

Facebook Like button small

The 34-room Church Hill Inn offers a cozy and charming environment, characteristic of an English inn, as well as contemporary resort–like amenities such as a pool and exercise room with sauna and Internet access.





Quick View Review

Church Hill Inn offers these accommodations:

  • We at DoorCountyNavigator say that the inn is absolutely delightful—from the lovely theme-decorated rooms to the English-style pub and hot breakfast buffet
  • 34 rooms on two levels in a cozy and charming environment characteristic of an English inn in a resort setting
  • Choose from Oversize English rooms with king bed or two queens or English Rooms  with queen bed; and decorating themes like golf room or songbird room, many rooms with views of garden and outdoor pool
  • All accommodations have bathroom, patio or balcony, TV/cable. Luxury accommodations have whirlpools, and two deluxe suites have whirlpools, fireplaces
  • A favorite gathering spot is the Honor Bar, reminiscent of an English pub
  • Guests access rooms from wide parlors, each with a theme to themselves (such as music) and outfitted with refrigerators for guests who do not have refrigs in rooms

Other features include:

  • Open all-year, walking distance to Sister Bay downtown area and nearby Country Walk Shops
  • Heated outdoor pool, exercise room with sauna
  • New in 2012: Gateway Spa with customized massages, spa packages
  • Hot breakfast served in remodeled dining room and often features artichoke soufflé, breakfast, quiche, French toast  
  • DoorCountyNavigator Recommended - so be sure to tell them that DoorCountyNavigator sent you!

Call to make your reservation today!

Church Hill Inn

2393 Gateway Dr.

Sister Bay, WI   54235
Telephone (800)422-4906

Full Trusted Review

“We try to give our guests the best of both worlds—to have the feel of a bed and breakfast with the amenities of a hotel,” says Mike Goldstone, innkeeper.

The pretty yellow inn sits on a hill and offers a location within walking distance to Sister Bay’s downtown area and the nearby Country Walk shops.


The two-level building has 17 rooms on level one and 17 on the second floor. Guests can choose from a wide variety of accommodations: the English room with one queen-size bed or an oversize English bedroom with one king-size bed or two queen-size beds. Luxury accommodations offer whirlpools, and two deluxe suites have whirlpools and fireplaces.

All accommodations offer private bath, a balcony or patio, television/cable, telephone and individually controlled air conditioning and heat. Guests (adults only) also indulge in luxury linens and triple sheeting on beds.

Sister Bay Wi lodging  Church Hill Inn B&B, Door County Trusted ReviewAnd if you have seen one room at Church Hill Inn, you have, well, seen just one room. Here, accommodations have varying decorating themes, so you may have to come a few times to find a favorite. For example, there’s the songbird room adorned with prints of birds on the walls and wooden birdhouses all around.

The golf room has sporting memorabilia including a photo of Jack Nicklaus with three other professional players. Most rooms offer views of the gardens or the outdoor pool, which is heated and open May through September.

Guests access their rooms from wide parlors, providing additional places to sit and enjoy a fire in the gas fireplace and admire the pretty antiques and reproductions accenting the areas. Each parlor also has a refrigerator, accessible to guests who do not have an in-room refrigerator.

“Each parlor has a theme, too: music, library, games and botanical,” explains Mike Goldstone, innkeeper.

A lower level exercise room is outfitted with a treadmill, Nordic track, stepper, free weights, exercise bike and sauna. A television and Internet access are also available here.

Gateway Spa
Added in 2012, a new Gateway Spa that offers a large slection of services from customized massages, to hot stone therapy, aroma-therapy and lots more.  There are even spa packages as well.  So check out the Gateway Spa's services - you will be pampered and treated royally.

And you may need to visit that exercise room after indulging in the hot breakfast, served in the freshly remodeled two-story dining room. Three hot entrees are offered daily. Specialties of the house include artichoke soufflé, breakfast quiche, French toast, scrambled eggs and oatmeal.

Bakery goods such as English toasting bread and banana muffins are also available. On the daily menu are Church Hill Inn granola, fresh fruit and cereal.

A favorite gathering spot is the honor bar, reminiscent of an English pub, where people can enjoy a drink. Domestic beers and wines are served, and complimentary tea and coffee are available throughout the day.

“People just love to hang out here,” Mike says.

The innkeepers are proud that Church Hill Inn is a destination onto itself.

“We get a lot of couples who come together and girlfriends who come together. They reunite each year as a group. And they just want to be here,” Mike says.

After taking the tour of Church Hill Inn, we can certainly understand why. This is a lovely place to stay; the decorating is outstanding and amenities abound. We think you will enjoy!

Check Availability button
Be sure to tell them we sent you!

So give Church Hill Inn a call, and let them know chartered your way up that hill.

For your convenience, here is a peek at their website. To open it fully, click the link on the lower left of the frame.

Click here to open full page